Title: Christmas at Crownthorn Manor – A Yuletide Ghost Story
Author: Chris McGurk
Publication Date: December 19, 2019
Genres: Young Adult, Holiday, Paranormal, Contemporary
Length: 27 pages
Source: I received a free copy from the author.
Rating: 3 Stars
Three brothers travelling home for Christmas become waylaid in a fierce snowstorm. Pulling up at an old manor house, they think they are in luck when the owners let them stay the night. But all is not as it seems at Crowthorn Manor on Christmas Eve… Reviving the much-loved tradition of the Christmas ghost story, Christmas at Crowthorn Manor will send shivers down your spine on your journey back home.
Content Warning: 1918 influenza pandemic, grief, death of children, World War I, prejudice, and suicide. I will mention the 1918 flu and Covid-19 in my review.
Christmas is supposed to be a happy time spent with loved ones. What happens to a Christmas that doesn’t meet these goals?
The 1918 flu is something I’ve been interested in since I was a kid, so I’m always happy to see it pop up in fiction. After the current pandemic began, I understood better why previous generations were often so reticent to discuss such things even years later. It can be painful to remember tragic stories about death, disability, grief, and suffering, and yet I think there’s something to be said for commemorating these topics in fiction when it’s appropriate to do so. Remembering the past is a way to honour the dead and to hopefully guide the decisions we make today to help everyone’s futures be healthier ones. The author sensitively included the societal, emotional, and medical effects of the 1918 flu here. They had excellent reasons for doing so that other readers should discover for themselves. These were some of my favorite passages in this short story, and I would have happily read more of them.
I did find myself wishing that more attention had been paid to how and when the author used the tropes of this genre. Anyone who is familiar with tales about characters who get lost on a snowy night and find themselves seeking shelter at a mysterious, old mansion will be able to figure out just about everything that is to come by the time they finish the first page. Yes, I know this was written for teenagers, but even with that taken into consideration I thought another round of editing would have made a difference. Tropes are good – or at least neutral – things in and of themselves, but they were utilized so heavily here that it negatively affected things like the character and plot development. I so badly wanted to give this a higher rating, and yet the predictability of it all was too much for me to do so.
With that being said, I loved the way the author incorporated modern technology and tools like cell phones, the Internet, and Google Maps into the storyline. It’s trickier for characters to get lost in believable ways these days due to all of the navigation and communication options we have in our phones when a road doesn’t lead to the place we thought it should, but these problems were all solved in logical ways here that worked well with the storyline and with what we already knew about the personalities of the main characters. This is something I always enjoy finding in fiction, and it has encouraged me to keep an eye out for what this author may write in the future.
Christmas at Crownthorn Manor – A Yuletide Ghost Story was a quick and spooky read.
4 Responses to Home, Sweet Home: A Review of Christmas at Crownthorn Manor
That cover is so pretty! It’s a short book, and those are hard for me to get into. It sounds good.
Yeah, it’s gorgeous!
It’s interesting that you struggle to get into short books. I have that problem with many books that are 300+ pages long. 🙂
And, yeah, this was a thought provoking read for sure.
This one sounds interesting! I also am interested in ways that authors can get people believably lost in these days of GPS tracking. It’s always great to see it done well!
Yeah, it was a worthwhile read for sure. I hope you like it if you read it.