Lydia Schoch

Title: The Case of Elmwood Ranch

Author: Deanna Grey

Publisher: Self-Published

Publication Date: July 15, 2026

Genres: Fantasy, Paranormal, Romance,  LGBTQ+, Horror, Contemporary

Length: 432 pages

Source: I borrowed it from the library.

Rating: 3 Stars

Blurb:

Elmwood Ranch is Octavia Daniel’s dream. A safe place to land after years on the road. But once she signs the paperwork and receives the keys, the nightmare begins.

Shadows move on their own, strange accidents become the norm, and injured ranch hands refuse to work a second longer. Octavia doesn’t believe in ghosts, but she can’t deny something’s wrong with the land she’s sunk her entire savings into.

Rae Jones is in the business of ending nightmares. She comes from a family of successful paranormal investigators. But she’s set herself apart from the Jones sisters by making their legacy into a commercial success.

After years of enjoying said success, she’s hit a wall. Whether it’s burnout or a full-blown existential crisis, she doesn’t know. One way to try to avoid a downward spiral? Take every interesting job she can get. And that includes one from a very stand-offish, nonbelieving horse rancher who thinks she’s a scam artist and the things she hunts don’t exist.

Octavia and Rae must figure out how to work together if they have any hope of solving what’s truly going on at Elmwood. As they build trust, they begin to build something more. Something that could either help or harm their chances of making it out of this haunting alive.

The Case of Elmwood Ranch is a sapphic paranormal romance featuring bisexual leads. This book is intended for 18+ readers.

Content Warning: Childhood bullying, neglectful parents, paranormal violence and injuries due to said violence, parent’s death by helicopter accident (not depicted), character paralyzed by by a car accident (not depicted), and sexual content.

Review:

Not every haunting is easy to resolve.

I loved the main paranormal storyline and thought it was well executed. It’s difficult to know how much to share about it in my review as the blurb skirted around the lore surrounding it and I don’t want to accidentally share spoilers. What I can say about it is that the characters took a methodical approach to gathering evidence about the haunting using both their intuition and certain types of modern technology that made it fairly easy for them to take note of the odd things happening on the ranch. It was nice to see how seriously they took this mission. Sometimes characters in this genre become so wrapped up in figuring out what’s happening that they lose track of their common sense, so it was nice to see an example of people remaining cautious and sensible while also attempting to figure out what is actually happening on a property where people who have been left alone there have been harmed on multiple occasions.

As excited as I was to read this tale, the slow pacing made it difficult for me to justify a higher rating. I sometime struggled to remain highly interested in the storyline due to how much time it took for everything to develop and how often the protagonists focused on things that didn’t seem to be advancing any of the storylines very well. In my opinion, trimming back on those sections heavily would have made this a five-star read as the concept itself was incredibly intriguing and I did like the character very much as well. I hope to read more from Ms. Grey in the future and that I will be able to give her next book a much higher rating as she had a creative and descriptive writing style that was otherwise right up my alley.

Most of the storyline was concerned with who or what was haunting Elmwood Ranch. The sapphic romantic subplot, while obviously important for both plot and character development reasons later on, took longer to develop and was rarely if ever the main focal point. This was a good decision in my opinion as I tend to enjoy romantic works more when they are a small part of a book instead of the main course, but it is something I wanted to take note of in my review for readers who may or may not agree with my preferences there as this is definitely a subjective topic.

The Case of Elmwood Ranch made me wish for a sequel.