The telling or reading of ghost stories during the Christmas season was once a tradition in Victorian England. This series of books seeks to revive this tradition. As I did in 2020 and 2021, I will continue reviewing several of them each December until I’ve reached the end of this series.
Title: The Empty House – A Ghost Story for Christmas (Seth’s Christmas Ghost Stories)
Author: Algernon Blackwood
Publication Date: 1906 and October 31, 2017
Genres: Paranormal, Historical
Length: 58 pages
Source: I borrowed it from the library.
Rating: 3 Stars
Aunt Julia, an elderly spinster with a mania for psychical research, has the keys to the haunted house on the square. She invites her nephew to accompany her on a midnight investigation into what really happened a hundred years ago when a servant girl fell to her death. But the house may not be as empty as it seems . . .
Content warning: murder. I will be discussing this in in my review.
As one of the earliest paragraphs in this story says, “certain houses, like certain people, manage somehow to proclaim at once their character for evil.”
Jim and his Aunt Julia were the kinds of characters that make me shake my head. Their courage often crossed the line into foolhardiness, especially when it came to their reactions to a few frightening encounters with what was lurking in this haunted house so late at night. Sensible people would have run away shrieking the first time they encountered something that couldn’t be explained, and yet I did come to admire their stubborn insistence on finding out the truth about why no one could bear to live at this residence longterm. This investigation wouldn’t have discovered anything at all if they’d been quicker to run at the first sign of trouble.
The ending was disappointing to me because of how many unanswered questions it left with the readers. Without going into spoilers here, there was foreshadowing in the beginning and middle of this tale that was ignored in the last scene to the detriment of the plot. It was just starting to get really good when it suddenly ended! I wish the author had wrapped up those subplots the way he so strongly hinted at earlier. If he’d done this, I would have gone with a much higher rating.
With that being said, I did enjoy gleaning the few facts that were shared about the sudden death of a servant girl a century beforehand. This was a part of the storyline that didn’t need to be embellished upon much at all. Violent deaths like these often take on a life of their own – no pun intended – as future generations reimagine what must have happened, so it made sense to me to leave room here for the audience to participate in the retelling of the events of that terrible night.
The Empty House was one of those ghost stories that deserves to be read and discussed in detail with a small group of likeminded fans of these genres. If that’s the sort of analysis you love doing, this might be right up your alley.
8 Responses to Memories of Evil: a Review of The Empty House
This sounds neat! Though just from the blurb alone I can tell that the characters aren’t always the most sensible. A midnight investigation into a haunted house? Why not investigate during the day? I guess there’s a reason I’ve not been the main character in a mystery novel… 😉
Ha! I can’t agree with you more there.
You are great at finding these Christmas ghost stories.
Thank you. 🙂
How many books are in this series?
there are 18 listed on Goodreads, but this upcoming collection mentions 25 of them: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/32858794-seth-s-christmas-ghost-stories?from_search=true&from_srp=true&qid=srwzP8ASNq&rank=4
So I guess more are on the way maybe?
Of the 18 listed in that link, I’ve read at least 10 of them. Not sure on a couple.
We’re covered for a few more Decembers. 👻
Heh, yes, if th Toronto Public Library buys them! 😀